{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average American home maintained a selling price higher than the previous year on a consistent basis. That trend has now come to an end. Recent data from October indicates that the median sale price for homes has dipped slightly compared to a year earlier, marking the first time since spring 2023 that an annual decrease has occurred. Concurrently, the inventory of homes available has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have decreased to their lowest levels in over ten years, excluding the initial pandemic phase, and roughly one out of every five listings has been subjected to a price reduction.

However, it's essential to consider that the cost of borrowing has risen again. The average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has jumped back into the mid-7% range recently, following a short period of improvement. Thus, while buyers may find themselves with more negotiating power, the monthly payments remain challenging for many households.

This unique situation presents a noteworthy opportunity. Sellers are encountering fewer offers and experiencing longer times on the market, resulting in an environment where the list price and associated terms are increasingly negotiable. If you are in the market for a home this winter, consider what aspects might be open for negotiation and how to approach them with your agent and lender.

Understanding the Implications of a Price Decline

A national dip of less than half a percent isn't indicative of a market crash and doesn't imply that all prices are declining uniformly. Some high-end coastal areas with limited inventory continue to see value increases, whereas numerous significant metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced price drops of several percent over the past year. The state of the local market carries far greater significance than the average national statistics.

The overarching narrative suggested by national figures is a shift in the power dynamics of the market. As homes linger longer on the market and more listings vie for a smaller buyer pool, sellers are becoming more amenable to negotiation. This willingness can manifest in the sale price or, just as significantly, in the terms of the sale.

Price is Just One Aspect to Negotiate

While many buyers concentrate their efforts purely on the price point, in a high-interest environment, the implications of monthly payments and the cash required at closing can be even more critical. Reducing the price by a few thousand dollars will only marginally affect your overall loan. Rethinking how to apply that same money could yield better outcomes for your budget. There are several negotiable aspects that buyers may consider in a slower market, including:

  • A purchase price lower than the listing price
  • A credit from the seller to apply toward closing costs
  • Repairs arranged prior to closing or a credit allowing you to manage repairs
  • Seller assistance in buying down your mortgage interest rate
  • A closing timeline or move-in date that aligns with your needs
  • Inclusions like appliances or window treatments in the sale

Your agent will be aware of how sellers are typically responding in your area and can guide you on prioritizing these options in your offer. It's advisable to focus on requests that hold the most significance for you rather than trying to negotiate for everything.

Utilizing Closing Cost Credits to Mitigate Expenses

Typically, closing costs can range from a few percentage points of your loan amount, separate from your down payment. For first-time buyers, gathering that necessary cash can pose a significant challenge. A credit from the seller can help alleviate some of those costs, which decreases the amount you need to bring to closing.

However, it's important to note that limitations exist. Various loan programs impose caps on how much a seller can contribute, typically ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price, depending on the loan type and your down payment size. Generally, these credits cannot exceed your actual closing costs. Consult your lender early to clarify what your loan specifically permits to ensure your request aligns with the applicable guidelines.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates now above 7%, one of the most advantageous offers a seller can make is assistance with your mortgage rate. There are two primary types of buydowns.

A permanent buydown involves upfront payment of discount points at closing to lower your interest rate for the duration of your loan. Each point typically costs 1% of the loan amount, with the rate reduction varying by lender and prevailing market conditions. If you intend to hold onto the loan for an extended period, this option can yield significant long-term savings.

A temporary buydown allows for reduced payments during the initial years of the loan. For example, a common structure reduces the rate by two percentage points in the first year and one percentage point in the second year, settling at the full rate thereafter. For a $350,000 loan at an estimated 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest payment would be about $2,409. With such a temporary buydown, the payment in the first year might drop to roughly $1,952, and in the second year to about $2,176, reverting to the full amount in the third year. Covering this arrangement might cost slightly over $8,000, which sellers may prefer to offer instead of decreasing the price equivalently.

A temporary buydown is not a permanent solution. You must ensure you can accommodate the full payment after the initial discount period ends, and lenders typically assess your eligibility based on that higher amount. Should interest rates decline in the future, refinancing may be an option, but it's unpredictable when or if that will occur.

The Importance of Inspections

In competitive markets, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limit their requests to secure a property. Fortunately, in the current slower market, there's less necessity to forfeit those essential protections. Conducting a thorough inspection will provide you with valuable insights into the state of the roof, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, electrical work, and foundation before finalizing your purchase.

If the inspection reveals any issues, your agent can assist you in determining whether to request repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Opting for credits might simplify negotiations, as it allows you control over who performs the repairs and how they are managed. Still, the best option will vary depending on the specific problems and the requirements of your loan.

Get Your Financing in Order

Having negotiating power is meaningless without solid financing in place. When comparing offers, sellers typically favor buyers who appear more likely to complete the transaction. Before diving into the home search, obtain a full preapproval rather than a quick prequalification. Understand your comfortable monthly payment ceiling, as opposed to just your maximum loan amount, and evaluate quotes from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender about how they handle seller credits or buy-downs to avoid unexpected issues later on.

Key Questions for Your Agent

  • What is the duration for which homes in this area are remaining on the market, and how frequently are prices being adjusted?
  • Would pursuing a reduction in price, a credit for closing costs, or a rate buydown be most beneficial for my financial situation?
  • How do the specific condition and history of this property influence potential negotiation points?
  • What contingencies should I incorporate into my offer to safeguard my interests?

Concluding Thoughts

A softening market doesn't equate to lower buying opportunities, especially as mortgage rates are rising again. However, it does provide well-prepared buyers the possibility to negotiate terms that meet their financial constraints. With robust financing, a clear understanding of what matters most to you, and support from your agent and lender, you can potentially secure better deal terms than what was conceivable just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Floating Icon